Fantasy Books

Onyx Storm Theories: Trying to Guess What Happens Next in Empyrean Book 4

The biggest Onyx Storm theories center on the identity of Xaden's newly turned venin brother, the mystery behind Violet's missing hours after the battle, and whether venin…

AuravyreUpdated 6 min read
A jagged black obsidian dagger surrounded by purple lightning floating before a swirling dark purple storm cloud

Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Auravyre earns from qualifying purchases. This comes at no additional cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

The biggest Onyx Storm theories center on the identity of Xaden's newly turned venin brother, the mystery behind Violet's missing hours after the battle, and whether venin corruption can be reversed. With the Empyrean series heading into its fourth book, readers are scrutinizing every line of foreshadowing to piece together Navarre's secret history. If you just closed the book with your jaw on the floor, here is what the dragon rider community thinks is coming next.

Who Is Xaden's New Venin Brother?

The final moments of Onyx Storm delivered a gut punch that left readers scrambling for their highlighters. When the revelation drops that someone close to Xaden has turned venin, the word brother rings with devastating ambiguity. In the world of Navarre and the Tyrrish rebellion, brotherhood is as much about chosen loyalty and shared scars as it is about bloodlines. Several candidates stand out immediately, and each possibility breaks Violet and Xaden's inner circle in a different way. Brennan Sorrengail is the narrative dark horse. We already know Brennan survived a fatal wound through Naolin's desperate magic, leaving an unusual rune-shaped scar on his palm. If Brennan channelled from the earth during the Tyrrish uprising, or if his resurrection tied him to dark magic, his role as a tactical general takes on a chilling double meaning. He has kept secrets about ward stones and rune magic from his sisters for months. Garrick Tavis and Bodhi represent the chosen family angle. Bodhi shares Riorson blood and looks remarkably like Xaden, carrying the constant weight of being the secondary heir. Garrick has stood as Xaden's right hand since childhood. A betrayal or sacrifice from either rider would tear the rebel leadership apart from within. Then there is Prince Cam, known as Aaric Graycastle, whose royal blood and fierce hatred of his father's corrupt regime make him vulnerable to desperate bargains when traditional dragon magic falls short.

Candidates for the Brotherhood Betrayal

To weigh these possibilities side by side, it helps to examine their relationship to Xaden, their known motivations, and the clues scattered across the text.

CandidateBond to XadenPrimary MotivationKey Suspicious Clues
Brennan SorrengailAlly and brother-in-armsProtecting Aretia and military survivalRune-shaped palm scar, hidden journals, unexplained survival at the Battle of Aretia
Bodhi DurranCousin and blood kinLoyalty to the marked ones, living in Xaden's shadowShares physical traits, constantly positioned as Xaden's backup in combat
Garrick TavisFoster brother and lieutenantShielding Xaden and keeping rebel secretsUnrevealed depths of his signet, high-risk missions without oversight
Aaric GraycastleReluctant ally and peerAvenging his brother and toppling King TauriSecretive nature, royal desperation, willingness to defy dragon protocol

Whichever name gets confirmed, Rebecca Yarros built this twist to wound where armor is thinnest: loyalty forged through shared rebellion.

Can Veninism Be Cured or Only Controlled?

Ever since Xaden drew from the earth at the climax of Iron Flame, readers have searched for a magical antidote. In Onyx Storm, his internal struggle turns raw and exhausting. The red rings around his eyes and the whispered temptations from Sages prove that drawing power from the earth is an addictive corruption, not a fleeting choice. One dominant theory suggests the cure lies within irid dragon magic. Andarna represents a seventh breed of dragon whose lineage lay dormant for centuries. Because irid dragons channel distinctly and possess gifts outside the standard six dens, her full maturation could introduce counter-magic capable of cleansing corrupted souls. If regular dragons draw power from the earth through their bonds, and venin strip that same power directly from the ground, an irid dragon might channel from a completely different source: the sky itself. Another school of thought looks to ancient Tyrrish rune magic. Violet discovered that runes can store, transfer, and isolate magic without requiring active dragon channeling. If a rider can trap magic inside raw metal, could a specialized rune siphon corrupted energy away from a human heart? If you want a refresher on how the ending shook out before piecing together these puzzle pieces, our Onyx Storm plot breakdown walks through the closing twists chapter by chapter.

For building the same atmosphere at home, Romantasy Dark Academia Dragons Book Sleeve is worth a look.

Readers who like to keep that feeling nearby tend to enjoy Onyx Storm International Edition by Rebecca Yarros.

A cracked pedestal glowing with red lava beside an ornate stone pillar encircled by swirling white light

Violet's Missing Twelve Hours and the Battle of Draithus

The temporal blackout following the Battle of Draithus has sparked wild speculation across the fandom. Twelve unaccounted hours is an eternity in an active war zone, especially for a protagonist who narrates in the first person with obsessive, scribe-trained precision. Did Violet lose those hours to trauma, or was her memory deliberately altered? Scribe training taught her that information is the ultimate weapon, making a gap in her personal archive alarming. One popular theory posits that Violet's mind was scrubbed to protect Xaden or hide an encounter with a venin Sage. Another suggests she was taken across enemy lines and returned with dormant commands locked in her head, mirroring the mind-work tactics we have seen used against rebel cadets. There is also the matter of her second signet. While lightning remains her primary weapon, readers have scrutinized every conversation for hints of dream-walking, truth-seeking, or distance-wielding. If Violet used an unconfirmed second ability during those twelve hours to alter the outcome of the battle, the mental recoil might explain why her recollection went dark.

A shattered hourglass with black crystals and glowing purple energy standing on a mossy stone surface

The Lynx Deception: Shadow Wielder or Signet Mimic?

When first-year rider Lynx appeared to manipulate shadows, the revelation felt like a direct threat to Xaden's narrative uniqueness. Dragon lore in Navarre insists that shadows are exceptionally rare, historically tied to specific bloodlines and dragon temperaments. That tension gave birth to a compelling fan interpretation: Lynx is not a true shadow wielder, but a signet mimic. Under this theory, Lynx possesses the rare and dangerous ability to mirror or copy the magical abilities of nearby riders. Because Xaden was in close proximity, Lynx reflected shadow magic rather than generating it independently. A mimic signet creates incredible narrative stakes. If leadership discovers someone who can duplicate lightning, shadows, or shields at will, that cadet becomes the most volatile asset in the quadrant. It would also preserve Xaden's personal bond with shadow manipulation, proving his gift is still tied directly to Sgaeyl's rare lineage rather than being watered down across the cadet roster.

Are the Dragons Answering to Darker Masters?

We take for granted that dragons are Navarre's noble protectors, but their fierce secrecy raises uncomfortable questions. Dragons do not share their history, their mating habits, or their internal politics with humans. They dictate terms, enforce death penalties, and abandon outposts without explaining their motives. A growing theory among lore enthusiasts questions whether the dragons are serving their own pantheon of gods, or worse, playing both sides of the venin war to prune human overpopulation. In ancient Navarrian texts, the gods are associated with raw natural domains: Dunne, Amari, and Zihale. If venin draw power from the earth and dragons channel natural atmospheric magic, both factions might simply be harvesting energy that belongs to sleeping deities. Tairn's absolute refusal to discuss the Great War or Naolin's fate hints that dragon leadership hides uncomfortable truths from their bonded riders. If dragons originally created the wards not to protect humanity, but to corral them, Book 4 could force Violet to choose between dragon law and human survival. While you wait for answers, curling up with our favorite books like Fourth Wing and ACOTAR can help soften the book-hangover until Rebecca Yarros drops the next installment.

If you want to bring a little of that into your own reading space, Iron Flame: The Empyrean, Book 2 sits in The Dragon's Hoard.

Common questions

Who is the venin brother revealed at the end of Onyx Storm?

The book leaves the exact identity ambiguous, using brother in a way that could mean blood family or a bonded rebel comrade. Brennan Sorrengail, Bodhi Durran, and Garrick Tavis are the top candidates discussed by readers.

Can Xaden be cured of being a venin in Book 4?

Navarrian lore states that drawing from the earth corrupts permanently, but theories suggest Andarna's rare irid dragon magic or ancient Tyrrish runes could offer a way to cleanse or suppress the dark channeling.

Why did Violet lose twelve hours at the end of the book?

Her memory gap after the Battle of Draithus points toward either intentional memory modification by a mind-work signet, an encounter with a venin Sage, or the traumatic fallout of using her unconfirmed second signet.

Speculating about what comes next is half the joy of loving an epic fantasy series while it is still unfolding. Keep your copies dog-eared and your theories flexible, because Rebecca Yarros has a habit of shattering our neatest predictions right when we feel certain.

More from the Bookish Shop, chosen to match this chronicle.

Digital downloads · The Dragon's Hoard

A reading companion for this story

Original journals, trackers, and printable treasures from The Dragon's Hoard.

Optional. Everything you use here stays free.

Dragon Keeper's Reading Journal cover artworkFeatured

Reader's Sanctuary · Reading journal

Dragon Keeper's Reading Journal

An enchanting printable companion for your romantasy journey, designed to track series, annotate favorite tropes, and preserve the magic of every story.

$6.99View
Dragon Printable Bookmarks cover artworkFeatured

Dragon Treasury · Bookmarks

Dragon Printable Bookmarks

An enchanting collection of eight original dragon themed printable bookmarks designed to accompany your deepest fantasy reading sessions.

$2.99View
Ultimate TBR Organizer cover artwork

Reader's Sanctuary · Reading planner

Ultimate TBR Organizer

A poetic and practical sanctuary for the ambitious reader to map out their journey through endless worlds.

$4.99View

Original digital products, delivered instantly after payment. Sponsor and affiliate recommendations appear in their own labeled sections.

Turn this into your own reading year

Track what you read, grow a dragon shaped by those stories, and keep every quote and memory in one place.