Fantasy Books

Phantasma vs Enchantra: Which Wicked Games Book Should You Read?

When comparing Phantasma vs Enchantra, Phantasma delivers a claustrophobic, survival-horror trial through nine deadly floors of a haunted mansion, while Enchantra shifts into an…

AuravyreUpdated 6 min read
An ornate double mirror displaying a haunted hall on one side and a moonlit garden on another

Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Auravyre earns from qualifying purchases. This comes at no additional cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

When comparing Phantasma vs Enchantra, Phantasma delivers a claustrophobic, survival-horror trial through nine deadly floors of a haunted mansion, while Enchantra shifts into an expansive, aristocratic game of supernatural hide-and-seek across a gothic Italian estate. Both novels by Kaylie Smith share high heat, cunning heroines, and devilish bargains, but you should read Phantasma first because its climactic events trigger Genevieve Grimm's dangerous journey in Enchantra.

The Wicked Games: How Kaylie Smith Built Her Deadly World

Kaylie Smith introduces readers to a lavish, blood-soaked world where ancient demons, devils, and supernatural nobility treat mortal lives as pawns in high-stakes entertainment. The overarching series, Wicked Games, centers on the Grimm family, an impoverished lineage of powerful practitioners navigating debt, generational secrets, and lethal magical tournaments. In Phantasma, the danger is compressed and deeply internal. The setting is a shifting, predatory mansion controlled by demonic architects, structured around nine brutal trials reminiscent of Dante's circles of Hell. Contestants must survive mind games, flesh-eating apparitions, and their own darkest memories just to see the next sunrise. If you love stories loaded with immediate physical danger, much like our favorite picks for best enemies to lovers fantasy books, Ophelia's trial keeps your knuckles white from page one. Enchantra broadens the playing field. While Phantasma traps its cast inside haunted corridors, Enchantra moves the spectacle outdoors and into ballrooms across a sprawling, sun-drenched yet menacing Italian estate. The deadly trial here takes the form of an aristocratic game of hide-and-seek, where immortal predators hunt mortal players. The tension pivots from pure survival horror to social paranoia, masquerades, and razor-sharp political intrigue.

Ophelia Grimm vs. Genevieve Grimm: Two Sisters, Two Survivals

The starkest difference across both books lies in the sisters themselves. In Phantasma, we follow Ophelia Grimm, the eldest sister. Ophelia is a closeted necromancer living with crippling anxiety, burdened by crushing debts and the terror that her forbidden magic will be exposed. She enters the harrowing trials not for glory or ambition, but purely to save her younger sister Genevieve from financial ruin and demonic servitude. Her narrative feels raw, protective, and emotionally defensive. Ophelia fights because she must, and her magic is messy, visceral, and tied to the dead. By contrast, Genevieve takes center stage in Enchantra, and her personality brings an entirely different energy to the page. Genevieve is bold, outwardly rebellious, and driven by a fierce desire to unravel their mother's hidden history and claim her own autonomy. Rather than shrinking from society, Genevieve steps onto the hunting grounds eager to find answers, even if it means putting her life on the line. Her magic and choices carry a theatrical flair, making her journey feel less like an act of frantic endurance and more like a calculated rebellion against supernatural nobility.

Two ornate lockets sit on dark blue fabric before a warm fire in a mystical study

Blackwell vs. Rowington Silver: Choosing Your Supernatural Monster

A hallmark of the Wicked Games series is Kaylie Smith's ability to craft dangerously seductive, morally grey monsters who captivate readers looking for books like Quicksilver. Each book pairs its heroine with a terrifying supernatural entity, but their dynamic and tropes diverge completely. In Phantasma, Ophelia forms a desperate alliance with Blackwell, also known as Salem (Salemaestrus). Salem is an enigmatic phantom and literal Prince of Devils trapped within the house. Their relationship thrives on classic gothic dread, mutual distrust, and life-force bargains. Salem is possessive, calculating, and draped in shadowy secrets, offering protection in exchange for pieces of Ophelia's vitality and soul. The tension between them crackles with forbidden lust and the looming terror of demonic betrayal. Enchantra introduces Rowington 'Rowin' Silver, an immortal wraith and one of seven cursed siblings bound to the estate's gruesome traditions. Unlike Salem's ancient demonic menace, Rowin embodies brooding melancholy, fierce loyalty, and tragic elegance. Genevieve and Rowin are pushed together through forced proximity and a marriage of convenience, creating a delicious slow-burn dynamic. Rowin constantly wrestles between his duty to his cursed bloodline and his growing, feral devotion to Genevieve.

Direct Comparison: Phantasma vs Enchantra Side by Side

To help you decide which flavor of dark romance suits your current reading mood, here is how the core elements of both books compare side by side:

FeaturePhantasma (Book 1)Enchantra (Book 2)
Lead ProtagonistOphelia Grimm (Anxious necromancer)Genevieve Grimm (Defiant spellcaster)
Male Love InterestBlackwell / Salem (Phantom / Prince of Devils)Rowington 'Rowin' Silver (Brooding Wraith)
Core Romance TropesLife-force bargain, dark gothic romanceMarriage of convenience, forced proximity
Deadly Competition9 harrowing trials inside a shifting haunted mansionHigh-stakes supernatural hide-and-seek on an Italian estate
Dominant AtmosphereClaustrophobic horror, visceral dreadOpulent gothic masquerade, deadly glamour
Spice LevelHigh heat, open door with dark fantasy elementsHigh heat, slow-burn tension leading to open door scenes
Key MotivationsFamily protection, debt payment, survivalUncovering family lineage, independence, revenge

If you want to bring a little of that into your own reading space, Outus Dried Flower Resin Book Thumb Page Holders sits in The Dragon's Hoard.

For building the same atmosphere at home, TBR Jar for Book Lovers with 100 Colorful Notes is worth a look.

Readers who like to keep that feeling nearby tend to enjoy Romantasy Dark Academia Dragons Book Sleeve.

A glowing golden compass rests on two layered maps atop a dimly lit wooden desk with vintage tools

Spice and Heat Levels: Tension, Tropes, and Open-Door Pacing

Both novels deliver unapologetic open-door romance, but the route to the spice differs substantially between the two sisters' stories. Phantasma leans hard into frantic, dark fantasy romance where death breathes down the characters' necks at every second. The physical intimacy between Ophelia and Salem is steeped in adrenaline, shadowy magic, and dark bargains. When the tension snaps, it carries the sharp, urgent heat typical of dark fantasy survival stories, satisfying readers who love forbidden romance books. Enchantra, on the other hand, plays with delicious restraint. Because Genevieve and Rowin are bound by a marriage of convenience, their intimacy simmers over a longer arc. Smith layers stolen glances, formal ballroom whispers, and lingering touches before their walls completely crumble. Once the romance reaches its boiling point, it matches Phantasma in explicit detail, but the payoff feels sweeter and more deeply rooted in mutual vulnerability.

Reading Order: Can You Read Enchantra as a Standalone?

Technically, each novel in the Wicked Games series revolves around a distinct deadly competition with a conclusive couple arc. However, attempting to read Enchantra as a standalone will spoil major revelations and diminish your reading experience. The emotional stakes that drive Genevieve into the events of Enchantra stem directly from the fallout of Phantasma's climactic ending. Ophelia's sacrifices, the true nature of their family lineage, and the overarching threat of the demonic courts are established in book one. Skipping ahead leaves you missing critical context regarding the magic system and the Grimm family history. For the richest journey, start with Phantasma, let the horror of the nine trials pull you under, and then follow the trail of ash into the sunlit terrors of Enchantra.

Common questions

Do you need to read Phantasma before Enchantra?

Yes, reading Phantasma first is strongly recommended. While Enchantra focuses on a new couple and a distinct tournament, its plot deals directly with the consequences and worldbuilding revelations that occur at the conclusion of Phantasma.

Is Enchantra spicier than Phantasma?

Both books feature explicit open-door romance scenes with comparable heat ratings. Phantasma focuses on urgent, primal passion fueled by life-force bargains, while Enchantra offers a longer slow-burn tension through a marriage of convenience before reaching equal spice.

Who are the love interests in Phantasma and Enchantra?

In Phantasma, the love interest is Blackwell (Salem), a dangerous phantom and Prince of Devils trapped within the trial mansion. In Enchantra, the romantic interest is Rowington Silver, a brooding wraith bound to an immortal cursed family.

Whether you crave the frantic terror of Ophelia's mansion trials or the lush, aristocratic hunt of Genevieve's masquerade, Kaylie Smith's dark universe proves that sisterhood and wicked bargains make for unforgettable romantic fantasy. Pick up Phantasma first, light a candle, and prepare to lose your heart to the monsters lurking in the dark.

More from the Bookish Shop, chosen to match this chronicle.

Digital downloads · The Dragon's Hoard

A reading companion for this story

Original journals, trackers, and printable treasures from The Dragon's Hoard.

Optional. Everything you use here stays free.

Dragon Keeper's Reading Journal cover artworkFeatured

Reader's Sanctuary · Reading journal

Dragon Keeper's Reading Journal

An enchanting printable companion for your romantasy journey, designed to track series, annotate favorite tropes, and preserve the magic of every story.

$6.99View
Dragon Printable Bookmarks cover artworkFeatured

Dragon Treasury · Bookmarks

Dragon Printable Bookmarks

An enchanting collection of eight original dragon themed printable bookmarks designed to accompany your deepest fantasy reading sessions.

$2.99View
Ultimate TBR Organizer cover artwork

Reader's Sanctuary · Reading planner

Ultimate TBR Organizer

A poetic and practical sanctuary for the ambitious reader to map out their journey through endless worlds.

$4.99View

Original digital products, delivered instantly after payment. Sponsor and affiliate recommendations appear in their own labeled sections.

Turn this into your own reading year

Track what you read, grow a dragon shaped by those stories, and keep every quote and memory in one place.